Two pieces hit me today from the Uk, which inspired this blog post.
First off: Is this social media or a competition using social media?
Monitoring the various newslines this one popped up from the UK : “Visa UK rolls first social media campaign”.
However, this is a competition that is run over a social network, it could run in print, on TV or anywhere. It is good that Visa are realising social channels are where their consumers are hanging out as much as traditional channels, as consumers are taking in media consumption in different methods. But this Visa UK stuff is not new, but the headline is yelling “look at us” we use social media with a traditional message – so what?
…begs the question about social media, digital and how marketing lines are muddied with real society & business change as a result of the widening lines of new ways we choose to socialise and connect.
As I also went about my daily business of scanning International newswires – seems to be the UK dominating my thoughts today as I also came across this article from The Guardian
What stood out for me was this paragraph “But this isn’t the last word in the copyfight – not even close. Because disconnection for downloaders will only serve to alienate entertainment industry customers (remember that the most avid downloaders are also the most avid buyers – “most avid” being the operative word here – the 20% of customers who account for 80% of sales, downloading, concert tickets, box-office revenue, DVDs, T-shirts, action figures, etc). And because those who download most avidly will simply change tactics.” By Cory Doctorow
This paragraph is where I struggle with the term being used about digital media and social media, whether about policies or marketing, it is all mixed up together such as social media, digital, marketing, with a feeling of “out of control” and a need for policy and so on.
The technology is not the conversation, nor is the marketing message, there has been enough research to state that marketing to consumers has to fundamentally change beyond the efforts of certainly Visa UK and similar cases pretending to be some great new marketing invention because of social media, it is like being a marketing charlaton. Consumers don’t believe you anymore.
What I like about Cory Doctorow’s analysis is that whole industries are not getting the shift in society’s behaviour. Cory demonstrates this in his example of the entertainment industry, as he talks to the downloader being the most valuable customer. He also states those downloaders “will simply change tactics” as a result of a Digital Economy Act that is trying to be imposed in the UK that will NOT work. Again, the term in organising the social digital economy is like herding bubbles (up a hill!) comes to my mind. It just doesn’t work.
What we have is a growing more informed population, that will find a way as a result of technology to connect, share opinions, interests and so on, regardless of boundaries, or organisations, or even governments.
That is why a Digital Economy Act in the UK and Filters Senator Conroy is trying to impose in Australia simply won’t work.
My 17 year old son thinks I am mad to be bothered by such legislation – “we will just get around it Mum” – and they will. It is like trying to introduce prohibition on porn, alcohol or drugs – look to history, it never works and it never will.
All in all, social media for want of a term, in fact …lets change that term to a definition …”The advent of a wider mass of people connected and consumed social channels has led to a way we have (not will, OR about to happen) we HAVE shifted as a society in the way we demand to communicate and get our information & thoughts out there. We demand that is taken into account.
A 20K competition from Visa through a social network does not change the fact we know that is what it is, a promotion for Visa, not a benefit for us.
Even a filter or government act won’t stop us all from doing what we want and saying what we want, sometimes, loudly.
It has gone too far, we as a mass public, are more connected, we are powerful as a result with our opinions, likes and dislikes and we know it. More so our younger generation, don’t even think about it – they absolutely know it and don’t give it a second thought, they actually don’t give a dam about it, they live it.